Free Sources of Accessible Online Lessons and Lesson Ideas

BEAR Blog: https://bearadvocacy.com/

BEAR YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCGNmE6rIbNylg1qIN4FUsXw

Distance Education Resources from the National Federation of the Blind (NFB): https://www.nfb.org/resources/distance-education-resources

Virtual ExCEL Academy: https://www.pathstoliteracy.org/resources/virtual-learning-academy

National Homework Hotline for Blind/Visually Impaired Students (NHH-BVI): https://www.pathstoliteracy.org/resources/national-homework-hotline-blindvisually-impaired-students-nhh-bvi?fbclid=IwAR1_inqhXwdi4zXe0MfVwyFDCbxze7Gn7bt5oGlopkpI_9jLaCvsDbPPOAU

About Canes—What Kind? What Length?

What Kind of Cane Should I get?

I recommend the NFB cane because of its light weight and its superior haptic and auditory feedback. An added bonus is that NFB offers any blind/low vision individual one free long white cane as often as once every six months. Please consider trying one out; you really have nothing to lose.

The light weight of the NFB cane allows for a much longer length without hand/wrist discomfort. In fact, I find that NFB canes are typically lighter than Ambutech and similar canes that are 18-24 inches SHORTER than the NFB cane.

The materials used to make an NFB cane (carbon fiber or fiberglass) make the cane far more useful for haptic feedback. The cane user can feel vibrations from the cane as it touches different objects and surfaces. In contrast, aluminum canes tend to dull the level of haptic feedback from the cane, and the ropes inside folding canes can further dull haptic feedback to the cane user.

The NFB cane usually provides superior audio feedback as well. The NFB cane uses a small metal tip. The tip makes different sound when it touches different things. Rubber and plastic cane tips do not provide as much auditory information as the metal cane tips do.

The Longer the Cane, the More Information the User Gets Sooner.

Chest-high canes usually let you know there is an obstacle (or drop off, etc.) 1-1.5 steps before your feet would get there.

Canes at chin height or higher (my daughters is an inch taller than she is) give 2.5-3.5 steps of information.

These increased steps allow the user to walk more quickly and more confidently. I love my daughter’s posture and gait (the gait is typical and the posture slightly better than her teenage peers).

For a first-time child/teen cane user, I recommend getting a cane about four to five inches shorter than the child/teen. NFB canes come in odd-inch lengths (39 inches, 41 inches, 43 inches, etc.). Thus, if the child/teen is 61 inches tall or 62 inches tall, I recommend ordering a 57 inch long cane.

Questions to Ask A School for the Blind Before Enrolling Your Child

Regarding academics:

1. How do the school’s students do on state examinations? (Note that, on the whole, blind students outperform students in state examinations – but they do not outperform their non-disabled peers. HOWEVER, please note that you don’t want to rely too much on these scores – because you probably don’t want a school that “teaches to the test” all year.)

2.  Do the students learn what their regular education peers do? (The curriculum at a school for the blind should be more robust, not less, than a regular school. It should involve accessible art classes, Music Braille instruction, accessible physical education activities and recreational activities. Like regular education students, students at schools for the blind should have contact with people in the community, but they should also have the opportunity to meet, communicate with, and be mentored by successful, independent blind adults. As a teacher of blind students, I try to provide this for my students in regular schools – a school for the blind should do no less.)

3. What is the highest level of mathematics taught at the school, and how often is it taught? (Most high schools in this nation teach at least one class of calculus every year. When schools do not do so, it typically indicates (a) that they are too small to provide a

4. What science classes are taught in high school? (Again, high level classes indicate high quality instruction and good preparation in the lower grades. High schools should offer Biology, Chemistry, and Physics – every year. Additionally, question if the high school students take AP, IB, and/or CLEP examinations. These are tests that can allow a high school student to earn college credit. If the high school is not geared toward college preparation, it is likely not providing high quality instruction.)

5. If the school sends high-achieving students to local regular schools for classes, ask why. If the student ends up in the regular school anyway, why start at the school for the blind?

    (a) Will the student be prepared for the regular school academically? (Remember, his/her classmates will have been taught by teachers who are actively preparing students for higher level classes. Is the school for the blind doing so? Is it even able to do so?)

    (b) Will the student receive the accommodations to which s/he became used at the school for the blind? Are the regular education teachers familiar enough with blindness to verbalize and make other needed accommodations? Will you or your student know to ask for the regular education teachers to receive this type of training if the student has spent tears at the school for the blind without having to self-advocate?

    (c) Will your child be socially equipped to enter a regular education school with its class changes, lockers, social strata, etc.? Will your child feel like a “special student” – and not fit in at the regular school after having been at the school for the blind so long? (In my experience, non-disabled peers tend to accept individual differences much more easily in their younger years. Additionally, blind students tend to accept non-visual skills and tools much better when they are introduced early on. Growing up with one another is a great way for students to understand each others’ strengths and needs. Inserting a blind child into a regular school for a short portion of the day does not tend to foster meaningful relationships.)

Regarding blindness skills:

1. How many children use canes for independent mobility, and how much? (In my experience, many children use human guide, squaring off, and trailing a great deal – and in many cases, canes are hung up at the door of the classroom and the cafeteria, and children have no independent mobility at that point.)

2. How many children read braille? (Frankly, if an academically-oriented child “does not need braille,” I’m not certain why that child should be ion a school for the blind. If the child has intellectual disability such that academic literacy is not possible, it still makes more sense for a school for the blind student to use tactile marking systems.)

3. Are students age-appropriate in daily living skills? (The social aspect of attending a school where there are many other blind children is, indeed, important. In fact, this is an environment where blindness should not be an excuse/reason to refrain from engaging in most any activity. Blind children must learn age-appropriate independent living skills if they are to achieve independence in post-secondary education and post-secondary employment. If a school for the blind is not taking advantage of its unique opportunity to teach these skills in peer groups, I would be very concerned about what other opportunities and skills they are letting slip by.)

Free Braille Books

Braille Reading Pals program (for blind/low vision children from birth through seven years old), part of the Early Childhood Initiative program offered by the National Federation of the Blind (NFB)

Free Braille Books Program from the American Action Fund for Blind Children and Adults (AAF)

Temple Beth El Braille Braille Bindery—Individuals may choose from many Braille books in either contracted or uncontracted Braille. The volunteers of Temple Beth El Sisterhood provide these books at no cost, but they welcome donations of Braille paper, Braille binding supplies, and money to support this mission.

Seedlings Braille Books for Children’s 2021 Book Angel Program for V-I Children  

Braille Institute Special Collection

NFB Kernel Books (Stories by and about blind individuals, edited and distributed by the National Federation of the Blind)

ShareBraille—an online resource provided by the American Action Fund (AAF) to connect with others who have Braille books to give away. Search the site which has thousands of books listed, and request a book. The current owner will then send it to you via “Free Matter” through the U.S. Post Office.

National Library Service (braille, enlarged print, and audiobooks on loan; free delivery and return)

Braille Reference Resources (Literary, Math/Science, Music, Spanish)

Literary Braille

Chart of the English Braille alphabet  

Chart of all contractions used in literary Unified English Braille (UEB)

Full Code Book for Unified English Braille (UEB)

Nemeth Code (Math and Science Braille)

Basic Nemeth Code “cheat sheet”

Texas School for the Blind and Visually Impaired page about Nemeth Code for Advanced math (Algebra 1 and 2 and Geometry)

Nemeth Code Manual

Guidance for Transcription Using the Nemeth Code within UEB Contexts from the Braille Authority of North America (BANA)

Music Braille

Music Braille Cheat Sheet

Overview of Music Braille

“Measure for Measure: Achieving Equality through Braille Music” A production by the National Federation of the Blind (NFB) illustrating the importance of Music Braille literacy

Complete Music Braille Code guide, with explanations 

Spanish Braille

Symbols used in Spanish Braille, from the American Printing House for the Blind (APH)

Great resources from www.spanishbraille.wordpress.com   

Free Canes and Cane Travel Resources

Free Long White Canes

Long white canes provided through a program of the National Federation of the Blind (NFB) and the American Action Fund (AAF)

For blind/low vision children from birth through seven years old, the free Early Explorers program, part of the Early Childhood Initiative program offered by the National Federation of the Blind (NFB)

Instructional Videos

YouTube video discussing the importance of the long white cane and providing information and guidance to parents in the Hows and Whys of cane travel 

YouTube video, Little Long Canes, where master cane instructor Joe Cutter explains the reasons for early cane travel exploration and providing parents ideas for early instruction

Information about COVID-19 Letter from the U.S. Department of Education—March 12, 2020

In a document distributed on Thursday, March 12, 2020, the U.S. Department of Education addressed issues related to the provision of IEP services when schools are closing. Highlights are as follows:

If the school is closed:

  • If the school is not providing any “educational opportunities” to students in regular education, the school is not required to provide IEP services to students with disabilities.
  • If the school is providing some “educational opportunities” to students in regular education, the school MUST provide “equal access” to those educational opportunities as well as providing FAPE (free appropriate public education) to students with disabilities.
    • If the school determines that it cannot provide such special education services, the school should consider providing compensatory education services to ensure that all students with disabilities receive FAPE (free appropriate public education).

If the school is open:

  • If the student cannot attend school due to coronavirus infection, the determination is the same as with any extended student illness from school (missing more than ten (10) consecutive school days).
    • The school MUST hold an IEP meeting to change the child’s placement to homebound and change services, as needed.
    • If the student does not receive special education services for an extended period of time, the school should consider providing compensatory education services to ensure that all students with disabilities receive FAPE (free appropriate public education).
  • If the student cannot attend school due to a “high risk of severe medical complications,” the determination is the same as for actual student illness. If the student must stay away from school for an extended period of time (more than ten (10) consecutive school days):
    • The school MUST hold an IEP meeting to change the child’s placement to homebound and change services, as needed.
    • If the student does not receive special education services for an extended period of time, the school should consider providing compensatory education services to ensure that all students with disabilities receive FAPE (free appropriate public education).
    • PLEASE NOTE, however, that, pursuant to Section 504, the student may be excluded from school only if such exclusion is medically necessary. “The decision to dismiss a child based on his or her high risk for medical complications must be based on the individual needs of the child and not on perceptions of the child’s needs based merely on stereotypes or generalizations regarding his or her disability.”

You may access the entire document at: https://sites.ed.gov/idea/files/qa-covid-19-03-12-2020.pdf

Office of Civil Rights: Schools Must Not Violate Civil Rights When Responding to COVID-19 Concerns

March 17, 2020 OCR Press Release

On March 17, 2020, the Office of Civil Rights of the U.S. Department of Education issued a press release regarding online learning in the COVID-19 environment. OCR is the agency that enforces Civil Rights laws, including Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).

In this March 17, 2020 press release, OCR, “reminds decisionmakers of their responsibility in making distance learning accessible to students with disabilities, unless equally effective alternate access is provided. Online learning tools must be accessible to students with disabilities, and they must be compatible with the various forms of assistive technology that students might use to help them learn.” Assistant Secretary of Education for Civil Rights Kenneth L. Marcus also advised, “Students with disabilities must have access to educational technology utilized by schools, and OCR will continue to work to ensure that no student is excluded from utilizing these important tools.”

March 16, 2020 OCR Fact Sheet

The press release references a Fact Sheet (issued on March 16, 2020). In this fact sheet, the Office of Civil Rights recognizes that discrimination on the basis of disability (or race, color, or national origin) remains illegal discrimination—even in times of emergency. OCR further notes “Compliance with CDC’s recommendations should not create civil rights concerns.” The fact sheet also repeats the guidance issued on March 12, 2020 regarding school’s obligations to students with disabilities during this time which is outlined in this BEAR document (https://www.dropbox.com/s/t0kh9ema97xyqrh/Information%20about%20COVID-19–Letter%20from%20DOE%20of%2003-12-2020.docx?dl=0).

March 17, 2020 OCR Webinar

The press release also contains a link to a short webinar available on YouTube. In this webinar, OCR outlines the information set forth above and notes, “Anyone who believes that a recipient or educational institution has violated a federal civil rights law enforced by OCR can file a complaint at ocrcas@ed.gov.” OCR has made it patently clear that there are no excuses—none—for public schools that choose to provide educational opportunities for non-disabled students.

What Does This Mean?

No excuses

The Office of Civil Rights, the agency that enforces civil rights laws, including Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), has unequivocally dismissed the idea that schools are exempt from these laws during the COVID-19 Pandemic. There are no excuses.

It is telling that OCR reiterated the March 12, 2020 guidance issued by the U.S. Department of Education, “If a school district closes its schools and does not provide any educational services to the general student population, then a school would not be required to provide services to students with disabilities during that same period of time.” OCR has given  an “out” to schools that do not choose to make online learning accessible; that “out” is not providing distance education for any student. At the same time, OCR is forcefully reminding schools that, if they choose to provide online education to non-disabled students, they must ensure that students with disabilities have accessible means to effectively perform the same tasks.

Timelines for IEPs and Evaluations

Additionally, in its Fact Sheet, OCR references timelines for IEP meetings and evaluations.

IEP Meetings

OCR recognizes that IEP meetings need not be held in person, and it says nothing about schools getting timeline extensions due to school closures. These matters will likely be very case-specific, but schools that fail to hold timely IEP meetings during the COVID-19 Pandemic may find themselves out of compliance when schools, enforcement agencies, and courts  reopen.

Evaluations

OCR recognizes that some evaluations must involve “face-to-face assessment or observation” and that delaying these evaluations until schools reopen is valid. However, OCR explicitly directs schools, “Evaluations and re-evaluations that do not require face-to-face assessments or observations may take place while schools are closed, so long as a student’s parent or legal guardian consents.” This guidance is crystal clear.

When is Face-to-face required?

In order to assert that face-to-face assessment or observation is required for an evaluation, the school should NOT rely solely on past practices. After all, in most cases, all past instruction has taken place in a face-to-face environment. Assessments do not necessarily have to occur face-to-face now just because have been performed face-to-face in the past. Again, this will be a fact-intensive inquiry. However, schools using online learning platforms would need to describe why those would not work for the assessments needed. Parents and educators can help schools by recommending accessible online platforms like Zoom (https://zoom.us/) and learning which assessments truly require face-to-face meetings and which may be performed via distance.

Next Steps

Many parents and educators face school officials who are either uninformed about the law’s requirements or unconcerned about the law. Parents and educators may:

  1. Share these legal updates with schools (educators, administrators, etc.). If they don’t have the information, it is hard for them to act upon it. Help provide them the information they need.
  2. Be open and willing to negotiate. Yes, the law is clear. Unfortunately, laws take time (and, often, money) to enforce. Working together toward a common goal (like education), we can accomplish great things.
  3. Consider filing an OCR complaint. As noted above, OCR has explicitly welcomed complaints regarding these matters. Relevant links are found below.
  4. Consider completing the NFB’s Education Technology Survey: “The National Federation of the Blind is gathering information regarding the accessibility of educational technology used in our nation’s schools (kindergarten through graduate level). If you are a student, parent, teacher, or administrator who uses screen access software or other accommodations to participate nonvisually in educational programs or services, or if you are the parent, teacher, or administrator of someone who does, please complete this survey once a semester and contribute to this important research.” at https://www.nfb.org/programs-services/legal-program/education-technology-survey.

Important links: